Saturday, July 11, 2009

A Broadview of Banal Branding

On July 10, 1985, “Classic Coke” was introduced to much fanfare after a colossal failure of “New Coke” that Spring, after a huge public outcry.

One has to wonder whether the roll-out of the new name for Brink’s Home Security will be reversed in a few months, too, after much public confusion.

“We are now Broadview Security, the next generation of Brink’s Home Security.”

That’s the confusing message that welcomes people to the new Broadviewsecurity.com Website.

Boring, bland, banal, colorless, under-whelming, and a stupid pissing away of 150 years of brand equity.

This new name, announced by company officials June 30, 2009 and foisted onto the world by Ketchum, conveys nothing, other than perhaps weakness, blandness and dullness. Shame on the branding experts at Landor Associates, an otherwise top-tier branding agency, who were engaged to come up with this yawn-inducing substitute. Folks, you’ve got it wrong this time.

I feel very sorry for the Brink’s Home Security employees. They must be devastated.

I know a bad public relations move when I see one, and this could be a big one.

Ad Age Magazine’s June 30 issue quotes a real branding expert, Denise Lee Yohn, as saying, "Trying to transfer that trust from Brink's to a different name is particularly challenging [in a
bad economy.] People are looking for proven suppliers with reputable names."

No kidding. And not only is the name gone, the traditional Brink’s Badge logo will be replaced by a logo with two odd “boomerang-like” swoops that suggest an Internet ISP and seem lifted directly from credit card giant Citi, only rendered in light blue (a weak color.)


In-yard signage and window decals will look something like a white fingernail, or a real estate sign. Will would-be burglars fear a white fingernail-shaped real estate sign in the yard?

The Broadview Website explains that the company spun off from The Brink’s Company last October, and is now a separately traded company. They also reveal that The Brink's Company granted them a license to use the Brink's Home Security brand for up to three years after the spin-off.

So why not keep it until the last possible moment? Why not transition? Why not keep elements of the Brinks name, as some of the “Baby Bells” did after the Bell System broke up in 1984 (Bell Atlantic and BelSouth, to name two.)

Just because change must happen, that doesn’t mean you pick a crap name to replace a time-honored one. That means you try to continue a legacy that has served them for 150 years.

As part of my work with clients who engage me on retainer as a public relations consultant, I always undertake an audit of all materials - Website, printed matter, signage, the works - to ensure that branding is clear and consistent, and that it makes sense.

Most of the time, being vague is a business killer.

Something like “John Doe Enterprises” is a worthless name, because it tells customers exactly nothing about what John does. “Well, I’m trying to be all things to all people,” I’ve heard. Well, that’s not good enough. If you’re doing EVERYTHING, you’re doing few things well. And it’s not about you, it’s about perceptions about you by your past, present and future customers.

In 2006, Stephen Abbott Communications became Abbott Public Relations, in part because the old name sounded like it was a phone company, and PR was my major focus. In 2008, I launched Abbott Media, a company that writes and sells electronic books, explores New Media, news reporting and other writing ventures, because these had nothing to do with PR. That, I believe, is smart branding. [In 2015, Abbott Media and Abbott PR became Abbott Media Group.]

The Broadview Website claims the new name “represents our legacy, our future and our unchanged commitment to "Creating Customers for Life."

Legacy? Seriously? Broadview as a name is the OPPOSITE of building a legacy. But this is marketing-speak, not real English, meant to be understood.

I have no doubt the people at Landor are sincere, and smart. The work on their Website (which, tellingly perhaps, fails to mention Broadview) affirms they are an astoundingly capable firm. And granted, branding is not easy or an exact science. But like many re-brands, this one seems to have clearly come up desperately short in the common sense department.
.
Six Possibly Better Names for Brink’s Home Security, off the Top of My Head:
  • “ShieldHearth Security” - It even has a warm feeling when you say it, and you know immediately that it shields your home and hearth.
  • “HomeSecure” - Again, blazingly obvious and quick to grasp what these folks do. (Although if the company seeks to reach into business security more, this may not be the best option.)
  • “SecuriGuard” - Security and Guard. Simple. Direct. Too difficult to screw up.
  • “Solidus Security” - From the Latin for solid. In English, it conjures up the same thing. SolidiShield would also help us envision solidity.
  • “AmeriBrinks Security” - This one is admittedly tongue-in-cheek, but why didn’t they fight for the name?

Short link to this post: http://bit.ly/1McD2xY

Monday, June 22, 2009

Gordon Ramsey’s PR Nightmare, and How to Fix It

by Stephen Abbott

British celebrity chef Gordon Ramsey, star of the hit TV shows “Hell’s Kitchen,” “The f-word” and “Gordon Ramsey’s Kitchen Nightmares” is facing his OWN nightmare after a disastrous few days in Australia earlier this month.

There to tour the country and promote himself, Ramsey trashed (in his usual, potty-mouth way) a beloved national TV interviewer during a cooking demonstration. It had devastating ramifications for his reputation throughout the world.

On Friday, June 5, Ramsay participated in a pleasant, on-air interview with Tracy Grimshaw, which was broadcast nationally. She’s like a Katie Couric and Barbara Walters rolled into one. She’s 49 years old.

But during a food and wine fair in Melbourne the next day, Ramsey suddenly tore into her, calling her a pig and intimating that she was a lesbian. To back it up, a picture of a naked woman was shown on a huge screen behind him with the head of a pig and multiple nipples Photoshopped onto it. He also said her face was badly in need of Botox.

While he tried to laugh the comments off as a “tongue-in-cheek joke,” no one was laughing, least of all Grimshaw, who publicly attacked Ramsey on her program the next night, calling him a bully and narcissist, and coldly denying she was a lesbian.

“Truly, I wonder how many people would laugh if they were effectively described as an old, ugly pig,” she said, on-air. She also revealed that she’d agreed not to question him about his alleged extramarital affair during the interview.

She continued: “But I’m not surprised by any of this — we’ve all seen how Gordon Ramsay treats his wife, and he supposedly loves her. Obviously Gordon thinks that any woman who doesn’t find him attractive must be gay. For the record, I don’t and I’m not.”

To make matters worse (and yes, it got worse) Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd called Ramsey’s comments something that might come from a “low life.” Ouch.

While some have speculated that this all was a publicity stunt to increase his, or her, ratings (both strongly deny it) it would hardly be a positive stunt for either one. Ramsey’s reputation in Australia is in tatters, and as we all can see, this story is by no means limited to that continent in the Internet Age.

Stories in the London Times and various less reputable papers, as well as TV stations around the world, covered the flap. Google Tracy Grimshaw and the second entry is a video of her responding to him.

Reputation Management to the Rescue
So, what, if anything, can be done to repair Gordon Ramsey’s reputation?

Ramsey at first handled this reputation crisis badly. During a morning jog, he told reporters swarming around him that her comments were made to increase her ratings.

But later, he did take the first step by rather sincerely apologizing, on camera, during an interview that was focused only on the subject of his nasty comments.

However, much more must be done to repair Gordon’s tattered reputation - bearing in mind he still bears wounds from the aforementioned affair allegations, along with recent revelations that, hypocritically, all the food in his fancy restaurants isn’t freshly prepared and anger from disgruntled chefs in restaurants he has critiqued on his “Nightmares” show.

Ramsey could, though it’s a bit of a cliché, donate to, or attend a class with, an organization that builds respect for women. He can repair his marriage, if its not too late, and get his wife on his side - and by his side.

This can’t be seen as phony, and in fact, he must treat women with more respect, both in public and in private (though with video cameras, what’s truly “private” these days?)

He can also tone down his act a bit, and use maybe 50% less offensive words during filming. British television allows the “S-word” to be used on the air, and ALSO the “F-word.” Although he has faced censure from the agency that regulates TV in the UK for using the “F” word gratuitously - sometimes up to 150 times an episode. Check out YouTube for the uncensored shows.

Being seen as less abrasive, less nasty and less foul-mouthed will be part of the media narrative. The media love to see a comeback and that’s how it will play out - IF he takes these and other steps, as his own PR people direct him.

Let’s be honest, it will be a long slog back for him, and he’s probably lost fans, especially in Australia and especially among women around the world. But with a proper Reputation Management Plan, Ramsey could once again gain all of that respect back he’s lost in this horrible episode.

Visit Abbott Public Relations at www.abbottpr.com

TWEET THIS

Short link to this post: http://bit.ly/1McD88K

Wednesday, May 27, 2009

Public Relations in Six Words

Become known - This is the core of everything Public Relations does. If you and your business are unknown, you don’t really exist. Your profile must be raised in order for your services or products to be sold and for your business to flourish in the long term. At the core of Abbott Public Relations is the ability to help you launch a business or help make an existing one better known.

Become known for doing - Being known is great, but known FOR WHAT? If customers have to ask, “What is it that you do, exactly?” then your previous efforts at becoming known have been all for nothing. Clarity, precision and detail must underscore your core business. APR brings this to its clients with creativity and a sharpness of vision. We’ll work with you to clarify your business mission and will craft ongoing strategies to get that message to those who need to hear it.

Become known for doing good - Being known is wonderful. Being known for doing good is even better. Customers want to do business with companies that are socially responsible. Search engine giant Google has a slogan: “Don’t be evil.” While many companies aren’t evil, per se, they aren’t known for being “good,” either. Goodness reaps almost immediate benefits by generating good will for your company, and APR can let your relevant publics and the wider community know about that goodness with a clear communications strategy.

Become known for doing good within - You may know who your customers are, and may even direct a lot of attention to them. That’s a good business practice. But what about the customers WITHIN your company - your employees? Are you neglecting to communicate effectively with THEM? If so, that can undermine all of your external communications efforts. The first step towards positive growth and becoming known for doing, and being, good is to examine the assets you have working for you, ensure that THEY know the good your company is doing, and ensure that they are contributing to that goodness. APR can create internal communications strategies that reconnect you to your greatest asset, and that will set the stage for EXTERNAL growth and prosperity.

Visit Abbott Public Relations at www.abbottpr.com

TWEET THIS

Short link to this post: http//tr.im/apr6wds